First, for those of you who have reached out during the epic winter storm Texas has been going through, my family and I are safe. We had power cycling on and off every hour for 3.5 days and some of our pipes froze, but we were able to stay warm and safe, so we were luckier than many others. We now have power back and things are thawing you.
Now, on to something much more pleasant—pizza!
I know that pandemic bread baking has been a thing over the last year, so I’m not introducing something novel, but I thought I’d share an offshoot of bread-baking that has been bringing some joy over at our house—making pizza from scratch.
It all started with hubs falling into the rabbit hole of watching David Portnoy’s pizza reviews. There was one about a guy making pizza in his apartment, taking donations, and then lowering pizzas out of his window with a pulley system to those who had donated. Portnoy gave the pizza high marks and was impressed with the crust this guy was getting with a home oven and a baking steel. So hubs came to me to show me the video and then asked if I could research baking steels.
Cue me now falling into the rabbit hole too, lol. Not of pizza reviews but of pizza making.
One cookbook, a hunt for double zero flour, and a baking steel later…I starting making pizza from scratch. And y’all, it’s been amazing. Like truly. I’m picky about pizza and want a good wood-fired crust and never thought I could create that effect at home. I was wrong. Behold…
Although I would consider myself an experienced home cook (I have quite the cookbook obsession), I am not an experienced baker. So I was totally intimidated by the thought of trying to make dough and getting it to rise and shaping it and all the things. And when I first flipped through the cookbook I’m going to recommend below, I was like, yeah, I’m in over my head. The recipes didn’t even START until page 100 because of all the explanations and photos.
But when I actually just said, screw it, I’m going to try it, and if it sucks, oh well I ended up making really great pizza right out the gate. Crispy bottom, slightly charred edges and delicious sauce. The instructions LOOKED intimidating but, in practice, were totally doable. All that step by step instruction in the book helped so much.
So, I thought I’d post about the experience in case you might want to give it a try but don’t know where to start. I will admit that there is a bit of equipment shopping needed to get the right tools, so I’ll list what we bought below.
The Cookbook
Yes, I’m sure there are a million free recipes online. But I wanted a cookbook to walk me through every step with photos. I’d seen The Elements of Pizza by Ken Forkish recommended in numerous places, and I was not disappointed. The pizza sauce recipe inside is worth the price alone and it’s literally the simplest most basic sauce ever, but I could eat it with a spoon like soup.
This book has great photos, great recipes, and walks you through every step. If you get it, I’ve been using the “I Slept In But I Want Pizza Tonight” dough recipe. I like this one because I can start prepping dough around 11am and have three dough balls all risen and ready to stretch and top by dinner time.
The Equipment
The Pizza Steel
This seems to be the game changer. I have a baking stone. This is not that. This is literally a heavy piece of steel that you put in your oven and heat for an hour at high temps before you put your pizza in. It gets screaming hot and then when you slide in your pizza, it cooks in 5-10 minutes depending on what kind you’re making. It gets the crust crispy and gets you that wood-fired oven effect. This is the one I purchased. Just be careful. The sucker is heavy. Only handle it with two hands and when it’s cool.
The Pizza Peel
You’ll need this to slide the pizza in and out of the super hot oven. The cookbook recommends a wooden peel. I couldn’t find that kind so I went with a metal one. It worked well as long as I floured the surface enough.
A Dough Tub
I don’t know if this was 100% necessary but I already had one and I find it very useful. You can mix the dough by hand right in the tub and then cover it while it does its first rise. The bonus of this method is you don’t need a fancy stand mixer. I have one and never had to fire it up.
Something to blend sauce
This can be whatever you have on hand—a blender, a hand blender, a food processor. But if you’re making from scratch sauce from whole canned tomatoes, you’ll need something to blend it. I used my hand blender.
Specialty Ingredients
This isn’t a must have, but I’m passing it along because it’s what I’m using. I haven’t tried the recipe with regular flour, though the cookbook does say you can use substitutions. The “best” is supposed to be double zero flour. We were able to find it at Central Market here in Texas. My guess is you could also find it at Whole Foods or online if your local store doesn’t carry it.
Those are the main things you need. The sauce and topping ingredients are all basics you can get at the grocery store. And I know this list may sound intimidating, but once you have it, you can make pizza whenever you want!
So far we’ve made some basics like pepperoni and margherita, but we also tried a prosciutto and arugula one and the Brooklyn Hot Honey from the cookbook (it’s one of the photos above) and they were all so yummy. I can’t wait to try more.
And in a pandemic, with all the stress of the world going on, I find it really relaxing and satisfying to take on a cooking project that is slow and methodical and has visible results. Plus, it’s so rewarding when I slide that pizza out of the oven and it looks (and tastes) better than I could get in most restaurants. Highly recommend pizza therapy! ;)
So, what have been some of your pandemic projects?